Court case

How the Goldenberg affair unfolded

In the early 1990s Goldenberg International received export compensation from the Kenyan government for gold and diamond exports that a later judicial commission found it had not made. The Bosire Commission reported in 2005 and, according to news reports, urged the Attorney General to consider charging former Finance Minister George Saitoti. Courts halted the prosecutions of the main accused, others died before trial, and civil disputes over recovered assets continued into 2026.

July 1990 to today · 25 dated events · 21 sources
Where it stands now · as of 1 November 2026

No one has been convicted over the Goldenberg payments. The criminal cases were terminated by court rulings or ended by deaths, and on 31 July 2026 the Court of Appeal dismissed a long running refund claim against the Central Bank over the Grand Regency Hotel.

In 30 seconds: the turning points
  1. Jul 1990 Goldenberg International registered
  2. 1990 Application for 35 percent export compensation approved
  3. 24 Feb 2003 President Kibaki appoints the Bosire Commission
  4. Oct 2005 Commission completes its report
  5. Feb 2006 Kibaki orders the report made public
  6. 31 Jul 2006 High Court strikes report findings against Saitoti
Stage
1. Payments
2. Charged
3. Inquiry
4. Report
5. Court rulings
6. Final

Timeline of events

Overview · Jul 1990 to 31 Jul 2026 · click a dot to jump
199019931995199719992001200320052007200920112013201520172019202120232025July 1990: Goldenberg International registered1990: Application for 35 percent export compensation approved4 June 1992: Exchange Bank begins operating1993: Pattni charged with conspiracy to defraud10 August 1993: Pattni agrees debt to the Central Bank secured on Grand RegencyOctober 1998: Malaysian firm sues over Grand Regency deposit24 February 2003: President Kibaki appoints the Bosire Commission26 October 2004: Inquiry suspended in dispute over state lawyersOctober 2005: Commission completes its reportFebruary 2006: Kibaki orders the report made public13 February 2006: Saitoti resigns as education minister31 July 2006: High Court strikes report findings against SaitotiMarch 2008: Case against former intelligence chief withdrawn after his death2008: Grand Regency Hotel surrendered and sold21 November 2008: High Court halts prosecution of former Central Bank governor25 April 2012: Vetting board removes Bosire and NyamuMarch 2013: High Court discharges PattniApril 2013: DPP says he will appeal3 May 2013: Magistrate formally terminates the chargesMay 2015: Judicial Service Commission suspends Justice Mutava16 December 2016: High Court dismisses Westmont's Grand Regency claim12 March 2019: Supreme Court upholds tribunal finding against MutavaNovember 2019: Court of Appeal rules against anti-corruption body in Pattni firms case17 February 2023: Supreme Court sends Grand Regency dispute back for hearing31 July 2026: Court of Appeal dismisses Grand Regency refund claim
1990
Jul 1990
Turning point
Corporate

Goldenberg International registered

Goldenberg International Ltd was registered in July 1990 with nominal capital of 100,000 shillings, its two issued shares held by Kamlesh Pattni and James Kanyotu, then Director of Intelligence, according to the Bosire Commission report. The commission found no evidence that the company mined gold or diamonds.

1990
Turning point
Finding

Application for 35 percent export compensation approved

On 8 October 1990 Pattni applied to the Minister for Finance for, among other things, export compensation of 35 percent on gold and diamond jewellery exports, and Vice President and Finance Minister George Saitoti endorsed it with the words approval is granted save for the monopoly, the commission found. The report called the application a mere ruse and said it falsely stated that diamonds were mined in Kenya.

“no diamonds were mined in Kenya”Bosire Commission report, Judicial Commission of Inquiry into the Goldenberg Affair (Parliament of Kenya library)
· · · 23 months later
1992
4 Jun 1992
Corporate

Exchange Bank begins operating

Exchange Bank, linked to Pattni and Kanyotu, began operating on 4 June 1992, the commission found, adding that its proposed capital of 40 million shillings was never paid up.

1993
1993
Filing

Pattni charged with conspiracy to defraud

Kamlesh Pattni was first charged in 1993 with conspiracy to defraud the government, the Daily Nation reported. He later faced a 5.8 billion shilling fraud case in which former Treasury permanent secretary Wilfred Koinange and former Kenya Commercial Bank general manager Elijah arap Bii were also accused, the paper said.

🇰🇪 NairobiDaily Nation
10 Aug 1993
Money

Pattni agrees debt to the Central Bank secured on Grand Regency

According to the Central Bank of Kenya's account reported by the Daily Nation, Pattni agreed on 10 August 1993 to pay the bank 2.5 billion shillings, secured against the Grand Regency Hotel in Nairobi.

KES 2.5 billion debt to the Central Bank, as reported🇰🇪 NairobiDaily Nation
· · · 62 months later
1998
Oct 1998
Filing

Malaysian firm sues over Grand Regency deposit

Westmont Holdings, a Malaysian company, and Pattni filed suit in October 1998 seeking a refund of a deposit paid toward a proposed purchase of the Grand Regency Hotel, AllAfrica reported in 2026.

🇰🇪 NairobiAllAfrica (Capital FM)
· · · 53 months later
2003
24 Feb 2003
Turning point
Investigation

President Kibaki appoints the Bosire Commission

The Judicial Commission of Inquiry into the Goldenberg Affair was appointed by Gazette Notices 1237 and 1238 of 24 February 2003, its report states. Justice Samuel Bosire of the Court of Appeal chaired it, with Peter Le Pelley as commissioner. Its terms of reference were widened on 29 July 2003, and Nzamba Kitonga replaced Justice D.K. Aganyanya as vice chairman on 29 October 2003.

· · · 20 months later
2004
26 Oct 2004
Legal step

Inquiry suspended in dispute over state lawyers

The commission suspended its hearings on their 282nd day after a High Court order reinstated two lawyers it had ejected, AFP reported. Commissioner Peter Le Pelley called the order one sided.

🇰🇪 NairobiMail and Guardian (AFP)
2005
2006
Feb 2006
Turning point
Statement

Kibaki orders the report made public

President Kibaki ordered the immediate public release of the report, IRIN reported. It said the report implicated Pattni, as founder of Goldenberg International, and Saitoti, finance minister at the time and education minister in 2006, and that the scheme cost Kenya more than 10 percent of annual GDP in the 1990s.

“The release of this report marks the beginning of a new phase in the war against corruption.”President Mwai Kibaki, The New Humanitarian (IRIN)
🇰🇪 NairobiThe New Humanitarian (IRIN)
13 Feb 2006
Leadership

Saitoti resigns as education minister

George Saitoti resigned as education minister on Monday 13 February 2006 after the report urged the Attorney General to consider whether he should face charges, the Guardian reported. Kibaki accepted the resignation so investigations could proceed.

“I urge all Kenyans to exercise patience as the relevant arms of government carry out investigations into these issues.”President Mwai Kibaki, Mail and Guardian (Guardian Unlimited)
31 Jul 2006
Turning point
Ruling

High Court strikes report findings against Saitoti

A High Court bench of Justices Joseph Nyamu, Roselyne Wendoh and Mathew Emukule ordered the parts of the report concerning Saitoti removed and halted his prosecution, the Daily Nation and The Standard reported. Nyamu found the commission's conclusions on Saitoti irrational and held the payments had been approved by Parliament.

🇰🇪 NairobiDaily NationThe Standard
· · · 19 months later
2008
Mar 2008
Legal step

Case against former intelligence chief withdrawn after his death

The state withdrew its Goldenberg case against James Kanyotu in March 2008, after he died the previous month, Capital FM and the Daily Nation reported.

🇰🇪 NairobiCapital FMDaily Nation
2008
Money

Grand Regency Hotel surrendered and sold

Pattni surrendered the Grand Regency Hotel to the Central Bank of Kenya to settle about 2.5 billion shillings owed through Exchange Bank, Capital FM reported via AllAfrica. The bank sold it to Libyan investors in 2008, which the Daily Nation said led to a commission of inquiry, the Cockar Commission.

21 Nov 2008
Ruling

High Court halts prosecution of former Central Bank governor

Justices Nyamu, Wendoh and George Dulu stopped the prosecution of former Central Bank governor Eric Kotut and struck out the report's paragraphs implicating him, finding the inquiry biased and the delay unfair, Capital FM reported. The Daily Nation reported that Attorney General Amos Wako told the DPP to appeal.

“It would be a miscarriage of justice should we uphold the report”High Court bench, as reported by Capital FM, Capital FM
🇰🇪 NairobiCapital FMDaily Nation
· · · 41 months later
2012
25 Apr 2012
Leadership

Vetting board removes Bosire and Nyamu

The Judges and Magistrates Vetting Board found Justice Bosire and Justice Nyamu unsuitable to continue as appeal judges, The Standard reported, citing Bosire's refusal as commission chairman to obey a court order on summoning witnesses and Nyamu's Goldenberg rulings.

“He simply treated it as if it was not binding on him and ignored it.”Judges and Magistrates Vetting Board, on Justice Bosire, The Standard
🇰🇪 NairobiThe StandardDaily Nation
2013
Mar 2013
Turning point
Ruling

High Court discharges Pattni

Justice Joseph Mutava discharged Pattni and Elijah arap Bii of all charges and barred further prosecution, finding their rights had been violated by delay, lost documents, unavailable witnesses and the settlements with the Central Bank, the Daily Nation reported. Business Daily said the judgment was dated 20 March, while a DPP letter quoted by Capital FM referred to the decision of 25 March 2013.

“Mr Pattni's fundamental rights and freedoms have been violated by the State in several respects.”Justice Joseph Mutava, Daily Nation
Apr 2013
Statement

DPP says he will appeal

Director of Public Prosecutions Keriako Tobiko said he would appeal the ruling, the Daily Nation and Capital FM reported.

🇰🇪 NairobiDaily NationCapital FM
3 May 2013
Closure

Magistrate formally terminates the charges

Pattni left the Milimani magistrate's court a free man after the criminal charges were formally terminated in line with the High Court judgment, Business Daily reported.

🇰🇪 NairobiBusiness Daily
· · · 24 months later
2015
May 2015
Investigation

Judicial Service Commission suspends Justice Mutava

Citizen Digital reported that the Judicial Service Commission suspended Justice Mutava in May 2015 and that a tribunal appointed by President Uhuru Kenyatta began examining complaints against him, including from the Law Society of Kenya, over matters that included his Pattni ruling.

🇰🇪 NairobiCitizen Digital
· · · 20 months later
2016
16 Dec 2016
Ruling

High Court dismisses Westmont's Grand Regency claim

Justice Richard Mwongo dismissed Westmont's claim against the Central Bank, finding the company failed to pay the balance of the purchase price on time, the Daily Nation reported. The Court of Appeal later dismissed the appeal in 2017 after the company failed to deposit security, the paper said.

🇰🇪 NairobiDaily Nation
· · · 27 months later
2019
12 Mar 2019
Ruling

Supreme Court upholds tribunal finding against Mutava

The Supreme Court dismissed Mutava's appeal and upheld the tribunal's recommendation that he be removed from office, finding his conduct amounted to gross misconduct, The Star and Kenyans.co.ke reported. Kenyans.co.ke linked his removal to the Pattni ruling.

🇰🇪 NairobiThe Star (Kenya)Kenyans.co.ke
Nov 2019
Ruling

Court of Appeal rules against anti-corruption body in Pattni firms case

The Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal by the former Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission and upheld a 10 million shilling instruction fee it had been ordered to pay two companies, The Citizen reported. Kenyans.co.ke, citing Business Daily, identified them as the Pattni linked firms Marshalls East Africa and Delphis Bank.

· · · 40 months later
2023
17 Feb 2023
Ruling

Supreme Court sends Grand Regency dispute back for hearing

The Supreme Court directed the Court of Appeal to hear Westmont's Grand Regency appeal on its merits, the Daily Nation reported.

🇰🇪 NairobiDaily Nation
· · · 41 months later
2026
31 Jul 2026
Turning point
Ruling

Court of Appeal dismisses Grand Regency refund claim

Justices Joel Ngugi, Nduma Nderi and Katwa Kigen dismissed the 185.5 million shilling refund claim by Westmont and Pattni, finding the money was lawfully applied by the Central Bank to Exchange Bank's liabilities, AllAfrica reported, citing Capital FM. The bank's counterclaim was also dismissed. The Standard reported that the Court of Appeal had ended a claim against the bank over the hotel worth more than 3.5 billion shillings.

KES 185.5 million refund claim dismissed🇰🇪 NairobiAllAfrica (Capital FM)The Standard

Related timelines

Sources

21 records, ranked by type
  1. 1Official recordOct 2005
    Report of the Judicial Commission of Inquiry into the Goldenberg Affair
    Judicial Commission of Inquiry into the Goldenberg Affair (Parliament of Kenya library) · libraryir.parliament.go.ke
  2. 2Government documentOct 2005
    Report of the Judicial Commission of Inquiry into the Goldenberg Affair (catalogue record)
    Parliament of Kenya Library · libraryir.parliament.go.ke
  3. 3News report26 Oct 2004
    Kenya financial scandal inquiry suspended (Sapa-AFP)
    Mail and Guardian (AFP) · mg.co.za
  4. 4News report13 Feb 2006
    Report on graft scandal made public
    The New Humanitarian (IRIN) · thenewhumanitarian.org
  5. 5News report14 Feb 2006
    Kenyan ministers resign over sleaze claims
    Mail and Guardian (Guardian Unlimited) · mg.co.za
  6. 6News reportMay 2012
    How ego fight over Goldenberg claimed Bosire and Nyamu careers
    Daily Nation · nation.africa
  7. 7News report26 Apr 2012
    Scandals and past rulings end careers of four senior judges
    The Standard · standardmedia.co.ke
  8. 8News report21 Nov 2008
    Goldenberg: Now Kotut is cleared
    Capital FM · capitalfm.co.ke
  9. 9News reportNov 2008
    Is this the end of Goldenberg cases?
    Daily Nation · nation.africa
  10. 10News reportApr 2013
    Pattni cleared in Goldenberg scam
    Daily Nation · nation.africa
  11. 11News report21 Apr 2013
    Judge defiant after clearing Pattni of Goldenberg scam
    Business Daily · businessdailyafrica.com
  12. 12News report3 May 2013
    Court formally terminates Goldenberg case
    Business Daily · businessdailyafrica.com
  13. 13News reportApr 2013
    DPP to file appeal in Pattni's Sh5.8bn case
    Capital FM · capitalfm.co.ke
  14. 14News report2015
    Tribunal probing Justice Mutava over Goldenberg begins sittings
    Citizen Digital · citizen.digital
  15. 15News report17 Mar 2019
    How Kamlesh Pattni cost Judge Joseph Mutava his job
    Kenyans.co.ke · kenyans.co.ke
  16. 16News reportFeb 2023
    The unending Regency hotel sale saga
    Daily Nation · nation.africa
  17. 17News report6 Aug 2026
    Kenya: Court dismisses Sh185.5mn Grand Regency refund claim against CBK (Capital FM)
    AllAfrica (Capital FM) · allafrica.com
  18. 18News report18 Nov 2019
    Billionaire Kamlesh Pattni wins millions after beating govt at own game
    Kenyans.co.ke · kenyans.co.ke
  19. 19News report18 Nov 2019
    Kenya government loses appeal in the Goldenberg scandal
    The Citizen (Tanzania) · thecitizen.co.tz
  20. 20News report12 Mar 2019
    Justice Mutava should leave office, Supreme Court
    The Star (Kenya) · the-star.co.ke
  21. 21News report6 Aug 2026
    Court ends Sh3.5b claim against CBK in Goldenberg hotel saga
    The Standard · standardmedia.co.ke

Last updated 1 November 2026. Spotted an error? See corrections. Every event links to the record it comes from. Allegations are attributed to whoever made them.